Oil Options
- Canola oil: neutral taste; tolerates high heat; goes with nearly any topping
- Olive oil: familiar and typically light flavor; tolerates medium-high heat; goes with most toppings
- Sesame oil: stronger taste that adds a unique flavor; tolerates high heat; coordinate with toppings
- Coconut oil: traditionally used by movie theaters, but I’ve never tried it; tolerates high heat
- Other oils: can be fun to experiment; oils with a high smoke point are best
Topping Options
The best part of homemade, stovetop popcorn is your toppings options are only limited by your tolerance for experimentation. Also, you and whoever you are enjoying this with can each add your own favorite topping, for a custom experience. Here are some options, but don’t feel limited by this.
- Salt, especially if you have a seasoned salt, like a smoked salt or chili-lime salt
- Melted butter and salt, for that classic movie-theater experience
- Salt and black pepper
- Zaatar (my husband’s favorite)
- Salt, smoked paprika, pinch of cayenne or chipotle powder (my favorite, requires a spoon to eat)
- Sweet drizzle: honey (1 tbsp), melted butter (2 tbsp), and cinnamon (1/4 tsp); mix together, then drizzle on top
- Dulse (or other seaweed flakes / nori), and consider adding sesame seeds
- Nutritional yeast (which I like sometimes, but not frequently)
Stovetop Popcorn
Equipment
- Large saucepot or other large (>6 quart) lidded pot, preferably one with a heavy bottom
Ingredients
- ¼ cup popcorn kernels
- 2 tbsp oil
Instructions
- Add the 2 tbsp oil to a heavy-bottomed pot. Place just three popcorn kernels in the pot. Cover and heat over medium heat. After a few minutes, the kernels will pop, which is how you know the pot and oil is preheated.2 tbsp oil
- Once you hear the kernels pop, turn off the heat and remove the pot from the burner. Add all of the remaining kernels of popcorn and cover the pot again with the lid. (No need to remove the popped kernels.) Gently shake and toss the pot for 10 seconds or so, the coat the kernels in the warmed oil.¼ cup popcorn kernels
- Wait 30-45 seconds – this is an important step in preheating the added kernels. Then place the pot back on the stove and turn the heat to medium. After another 2-5 minutes, the kernels will start popping.
- Once they start popping, it will be done popping in 30-90 seconds. During that time:Gently shake the pot 2-3 times, while keeping it on/near the heat. Carefully lift one side of the lid to allow steam to escape. This step, done carefully, will lead to a crispier, better popcorn. But be careful, because the little popcorns come rocketing out with some force, so you want to tip the lid open just enough to allow a tiny bit of steam to get out.
- Once you don’t hear popping for a few seconds, remove from heat and divide into large serving bowls. Immediately add your favorite topping (see reverse), toss well, and serve.